I wouldn’t perhaps go quite so far as to say that the advantage of not having to watch American Idol outweighs the pleasure of seeing and hearing David Archuleta sing, but it’s getting close. When one of the three songs earmarked for a seventeen year-old crooner with a thick vein of soul is selected by a nearly sixty year-old television producer whose most impressive previous credits include “TV Nightmares,” “Animals Do the Funniest Things,” and “Hidden Talents of the Rich and Famous,” you know (if you don’t already) that you are decidedly not the beneficiary of the most sophisticated musical presentation on the planet. And that’s too bad. Because David Archuleta is above this nonsense.
And that’s one of the reasons why I hope to God he doesn’t win it.
I realize that these are sacrilegious words to many of David’s fans, but history has already shown that actually winning this competition has nothing to do with eventual artistic achievement or success in the marketplace. But a win does demand a whole host of responsibilities, mostly promotional, that someone like David is neither interested in nor at this point particularly good at (and it’s really the last thing he needs to learn).
But most of all, the winner of this competition becomes saddled with the American Idol brand even more so that the runners-up, and that’s a dubious achievement to be sure. The question is really whether the American Idol brand is truly congruent with the David Archuleta brand, and the short answer is that no one knows just yet what the David Archuleta brand is. The worst thing that can be done right now is to over-define it with the heavy-handed mantle of “American Idol.” When David does finally determine the scope of his professional character he will almost certainly see the title as a hindrance more than a help.
In the beginning, it seemed obvious that David Archuleta was the quintessential American idol. Who better to serve as an example of young talent and national pride than a wholesome, handsome teenager from middle America with such refreshing humility, and manners that would put a diplomat to shame? But I’ve gradually come to see that the title–at least in the way that 19 Entertainment defines it, or even for that matter the way the majority of the American public wants it–is too narrow for David.
In many ways, David Cook is the ideal American Idol. He’s familiar, he’s predictable, he fits easily into a predefined genre with which everyone is quite comfortable. Because the scope of his professional character is already delineated the additional branding of American Idol won’t succeed in fully defining him. But perhaps most important, he’ll make people feel as though they’re choosing something a bit rebellious when in fact they’re choosing the most conventional contemporary archetype of them all.
The real rebel in this competition is David Archuleta. David fits no mold whatsoever, and that’s precisely why the press has had such difficulty trying to explain and categorize him (definable buckets being the critical workaround to having to characterize something truly original). Oh, the critics have tried glibly to pigeonhole David as a Disney type or a Christian singer or a boy-band figure, and there are perhaps elements of all of these in him, but none define him with any real measure, not the way the simple moniker of “rocker” defines David Cook. Originality is the true iconoclast, and indeed the only value that has the potential to really change the game, if not the world. I think David has a better chance of doing that without the crown.
As for last night’s performances, the first reminded me why I’ve carved out a slice of my life for this kid, the second reminded me how young he still is, and the third reminded me what a supremely silly production we’re all watching. I do think David was on the precipice of getting With You just right. He was close, and even started to nail it toward the end, but it was too late. And once again it had nothing to do with technical control but with command and control. David’s Buddha nature compels him to serve, but onstage he needs to lead. He can come to it naturally when he has an unambiguous grasp of the material, but the slightest doubts make him falter; not in his technique, which is so remarkably reliable, but in his dominion over the event. When David has dominion, no one can touch him.
Much of that will come with practical maturity. For such a prodigy, David is something of a late bloomer. This will, I believe, accrue to his benefit, but only if he is allowed to develop in as much of an organic way as may be possible, given the fact that he now has an audience to serve. Subjected to the demands of a crown, this likelihood would be further diminished. David belongs on a different stage than the one tagged with “American Idol.” The sooner he relinquishes that corporate meta-brand, the better.
You’ve got me thinking, Rascal. I’ve been of the mind that winning American Idol would be good for David in that the Idol people would want to see him succeed, would shepherd him as he steps into the music industry. Now, I’m not so sure.
Also, I’ll admit, I would love to see the delight of having won and delivered for his fans spread across David’s handsome face. The way he wears his heart on his sleeve, I can just imagine how touching it would be for all of us. That I would treasure. Plus, I want to see him drive off in that car. After your article, I wonder.
I want what is best for David. It’s clear that even if Cookie wins this thing, David will be signed by a major record label. And, I’m really excited that Natasha Bedingfield wants to write a song for him (as she said on the radio recently). Natasha could really give David a boost, head him in the right direction. I’d love to see the two of them sing a duet and collaborate on some songwriting. Whatever he chooses, I’m convinced David will turn the industry on its head because of his rare talent.
Rascal, you really ‘get’ David like few do, have mad writing skills, and have a music background that most do not. I think you should approach David and the family about writing a biography. I was going to offer to do it and donate the proceeds to the charity of David’s choice, but you, my dear, were a REALITY CHECK! You SO put me to shame in the writing department! :o)
Seriously, Rascal, you could REALLY do David justice, and he deserves it, don’t you think?. Give it some thought, my friend.
Rascal, you always get it right.
I truly abhor American Idol, but it brought David to us, so I will try to overlook AI’s abysmal practices. They are a malignant entity of which I pray David will not have to be a part of for too long.
His performance of And So It Goes was pure genius, one that I will enjoy long after Idol is over.
I await his musical career with unbridled enthusiasm. I’m a David Archuleta lifer!
Rascal, I usually agree wholeheartedly with what you write about David. Your insights are usually right on. On one important point I disagree. I think it IS important that David win AI. He must win because of what he stands for and who he is. David is unique, sui generis, one of a kind. America needs to vote him AI to break out of that conventional shell represesnted by David Cook. Voting David Archuleta AI will show that Americans can relate to the values and attributes of a singer like David Archuleta. Great talent plus humility and sincerity are vital qualities that can maybe transform AI as well. Crowning David Archuleta as American Idol may mark a new road for the future of AI. David has all the qualities we want to instill in our youth who are looking for a model in the contemporary music world. To pass over David Archuleta will mean that the old mold prevails. To crown David as AI may mark a new era for the American public. David needs to win because we need him and what he stands for. A great, great singer with great potential to serve as a model for our youth today. This may be the real mission that he will embark upon as AI. Our youth need Idols, wholesome, good, sincere, noble. A brilliant singer like David Archuleta can break the mold and lead us to better days. That’s why I hope he wins.
Spot on once again, Rascal. Thanks for your words.
I’ve been a bit torn about the AI machine for the past several weeks now. On the one hand, it’s brought DA and other to our attention, and as he’s expressed, given him a platform to inspire a wide audience. What a great opportunity!
On the other hand, the fact that it’s a business at the end of the day, has become unabashedly clear. The producers are there for a reason -- to get ratings and viewership up one way or the other. I understand that. But it still saddens me to some extent. DA may be better off without 19 -- I agree with you there. But I can’t deny that I would LOVE to see him come away with the title after all his hard work and sacrifice.
I’m with you 100% on his performances as well. I thought “With You” had huge potential. But it seems he didn’t quite have the preparedness and confidence he needed for that one. And who could blame him with the schedule prescribed by the AI machine. Still, I was glad he gave it a shot and was happy to see his good-natured acknowledgement that he didn’t quite pull it off. “Longer” I see as an effort on the producer’s part to keep thing as close as possible going into the finale. ASIG -- the only truly moving performance of the night. Amazing.
Watching this season, I realize how much I do NOT like American Idol. This is why i haven’t seen it since the first season. However, this year i had some time on my hands when the season started and luckily came across David. He’s the only reason i am still watching.
Last night was disappointing for a couple of reasons… but his voice was as pure and piercing to the soul as ever.
I agree with you. David really doesn’t need the title or contract or anything else that comes with it. Although it would be great to watch him win… i would rather enjoy his post-show career far away from the AI franchise.
I am so so excited to see where David goes from here. I know he is capable of great things.
thanks for your intelligent and beautiful writing that really captures the heart of David’s older fans 🙂
Rascal,
as always, thank you for clarifying thoughts that might have surfaced in my mind over time. I am disappointed in Idol this year, probably because I’m really paying attention this year, because of David. I am always proud of him. I love how you characterized the three songs — as reminders of his talent, his youth, and the show’s silliness. Spot on.
Although I understand fully your argument that the crown won’t help him, I can’t bring myself to stop voting for him. I think he entered to win, for whatever his reasons, and I’ll do what I can to help him.
Although David doesn’t need the title, and in fact might very well be better off without it, I still believe that Idol would be so much better with an Archuleta win. He’s the little boy who loved the show, who loved the previous contestants, who has never done anything but support the show. For him to win would bring the story around full-circle. And since I’m done with the show, it’d be a satisfying conclusion.
Thank you, Rascal. I was so angry after last night’s show, watching the obvious favoritism in David Cook’s direction. I just wish (as I bet many of us do) that our David could somehow win this and not win it at the same time. Wouldn’t this be great,-- “The winner is…..David…. Archuleta!!!” Screams, confetti, new car, special song, and then, “Gosh! I can’t tell you how much this means to me! Thank you so much, but… no thanks!” HA!!!!
I’ve never watched this show before, and I’ve sworn to my husband that I never will again (something about the kids having to eat frozen burritos and pizza every Tues. and Wed. night, mountains of laundry and ironing piling up, skipping exercise class most days of the week). I’ve never been a crazy fan of anyone before but this kid pierces me to my soul. I told my husband that if David doesn’t make it into the finals tonight, he’d better take the kids away for a couple of hours. As Charlie Brown would say, “I don’t think it’s good for a team’s morale, to see their manager cry.” Here’s hopin’, prayin’ and votin’
I’ve had mixed feelings about David’s participation on AI since the beginning. When he excels as he did last week with SBM and LMT, I can clearly see why this is so important to him and his career. AI provides the stage, exposure and challenge that seems to benefit him. But when the show is more about manipulating the performances to benefit the outcome of the show rather than the artists themselves, I wonder, what can the producers be thinking? Supporting these contestants with song choices and time to prepare would only enhance the performances, thereby enhancing the show.
I only want an Archuleta win because he wants it so badly even though as a parent I think he would be better off without it. He is so special, so talented that the thought of him in the hands of the AI machine makes me shiver. We all know something he doesn’t, how truly incredible he is and how the world holds endless possibilities for him.
I am a fan for life. God bless him.
I have a question for you guys. I thought that I read that Idol has the rights to sign the top 3 so you know they will grab David either way. Or do the the #2 or #3 people have a right to turn them down and go with someone else?
Rascal I have said that same thing over and over again this whole season. If he wins he will be very restricted in his musical choice that could cause great harm to his future career. I heard Sony and RCA are chomping at the bit to get him signed. He will have no problem with that and it will give him time to work on truly great music rather than slam dunk money making junk music. His only other choice is take the win, sue AI to get out of the contract, I think there was another idol that did just that because it was to restrictive. All this said, I still think If David really wants the title I hope he gets it but all David has ever said is “I just want to sing” If that is truly the case, winning AI is not in his best interest.
I like comment #7, take the win and then turn it down, that would go down in history forever.
Yes, David, win the whole thing and then run, run far away.
Rascal, how are you so brilliant? It’s defies description. Thank you.
For a long time, I have felt that David Archuleta’s talent is “beyond” the scope of AI. However, it is difficult not to get drawn into the competitive aspect of the show and feel that he needs to “win” to validate his abilities.Ultimately his “success” will occur as he matures and becomes the great artist we all sense he is capable of being.
Sources in the Archuleta camp are saying that David was planning to change-up the producer’s pick (Longer), but was “pressed” into doing a “straight cover” (only to get slammed for it afterwards!). Clearly the fuss over his father was based more on AI wanting to have control more than anything else. Having witnessed the way the AI people handle David and his talent, Im not convinced that they are the right people to be directing his career!
I have been reading your essays, and I always feel you are ‘dead one’ with your assessments. I suppose it would not be the end of the world if David were not to win; he’s young and he is still growing as an artist. You make some valid points that I can’t argue. However, I will still vote with gusto when David lands in the finale. Fate will determine if he is the American Idol.
I have watched AI every season and every episode for the pure entertainment value. There have been singers I liked over this time; some have won and some have not. Life goes on. However, this year David happened. Something about him has completely touched my soul both musically and as human being. I sure David would be freaked out to know how impassioned so many people are about his welfare.
Rascal -- Again, RIGHT ON THE MONEY. He is the REBEL. I don’t know how this amazing voice has captivated my soul so fully, but it has. I am so torn up about this winning vs not winning. But in the end I try to rationalize that he has won already. I have always thought, like you, he’s talent is far beyond this show, but I am soooo glad it brought him to us. I agree with #11, win and run, run, far, far away. But, in my heart I know he might be better off without the AI title and extras that go along with that title, that may not leave him as much creativity and growth as other options might. He JUST WANTS TO SING. And I think because of that no matter what happens, he will have a great, no -- unbelievable -- career. I will buy every CD and go to every one of HIS concerts I possibly can. And Rascal -- I will read every note you write about him, you are truly gifted in expressing all the feelings his fans have, but are not able to put in word form. Many Blessings.
I have had the same torn feeling about David A. winning. On one hand, it would be absolutely delightful to have someone of David A’s caliber win AI. It would actually give me more confidence in the American public and he would also be a great role model for people -- young and old alike. He would be idolized not only for his amazing talent but for his refreshing charisma and personality.
However, he never asked for most of what I stated above. He just wants to sing. He never asked for the fame, he just wanted to be able to entertain people and more than that -- show him who he really is on the inside. On the outside we see a somewhat shy, modest, slightly quirky young man who seems to have himself kept in check. On occasion we see his sensitive side open up for us to see. But through his music, he can express his inner most feelings and emotions and with a little mentoring he will be able to master that ability. He will be a force to reckon with.
AI has been both a blessing and a curse. A blessing in that it allowed the world to hear David A’s talent and to see something we don’t see much on TV nowadays. A true life well-mannered young man who is genuinely modest and sensitive and who’s talent is years beyond his age. The curse is the fame along with the corporations who will want to sell anything with David A on it and the iron clutches of AI over the winner. Going from being a private person to one in the camera lenses of reporters must be a shock and I truly believe that only now, in the last few weeks, does he realize the scope of what it means to be the winner of AI.
But what seems to answer my question for me is that he is still trying his hardest. He wants to win; maybe naively or maybe knowing what may happen. I can’t help but to continue to vote for him and let whatever happens, happen.
I’ve made my decision despite my earlier quibbling. David is giving it everything he’s got. So, I’m going to give that sweet, incredibly talented young guy everything I’ve got. I’ll back him to the wall.
If Cook wins, so be it. I will have done everything in my power to help David that I could do. We all know he has the far greater aptitude and will ultimately excel beyond any of them on the show. But, for whatever reason, David is giving this his best shot in an effort to win. I’m not gonna let him down. He deserves to win and America needs an Idol with the superlative character of a David Archuleta.
All doubts aside! Pedal to the metal! If David loses, Rascal’s words will be my solace.
I love this blog! I’m new and I’ll be back often. Thanks!
Rascal,
Having just read your comments has given me food for thought because of things I have noticed and read. A family spokesman for the Archuletas on a radio talk show commented that during the homecoming visit it was obvious to all that AI owns David. The family was kept in the background and David had to clear with producers every action he wanted to make to interact more with fans. David can sing different genres of music and probably needs to define
On watching the show as someone mentioned earlier, the best part of AI seems to be the beginning of the ride. From Top 3 on it becomes more manipulative. The confidence from last week seemingly evaporated after the 1st performance. Poor David looked so awkward on stage prior to “With You’. Normally when he chats with Ryan, they take a break, then he’s on. He was put on the spot and I think this rankled his confidence a bit. Other than ASIG, the whole night for him seemed unbalanced. I don’t know if all the bad press about his dad affected him psychologcally but he was back to licking his lips and closing his eyes more than we’ve seen recently. Simon also made some comments that were the worst I’ve heard him say to David.
Sorry about the unfinished thought. I wanted to say that since David can sing a variety of genres perhaps time is needed for him to experiment with the one he is most comfortable with for now. Grabby AI producers may not give him that opportunity and seek to milk him for all he’s worth. for a quick buck.
I was disheartened by the AI and media shenanigans last week, and by the dreadful songs (IMHO) chosen for him for the Top3--especially that archaic last one. Gotta wonder what they were thinking (and it doesn’t suggest anything positive for DA). I would love to hear our David sing the first verse of David Cohen’s “Hallelujah” while looking straight at Nigel. (Check out k.d. lang’s version of it, if you don’t know it.) But a sardonic comment like that would not be in character for him, beautiful though he would sing it! Truly, your points are all well taken, Rascal. But at the end of the day (well, night), I’ll be voting for the pure spirit of DA like mad next week, because he wants it so much and has worked so hard to get it. And wouldn’t it be a terrific statement about our collective consciousness, if it can reach that high out of the AI miasma and mediocrity for him to win? Beyond that, all I can do is wish the very best for David, whatever that may turn out to be.
Well said Rascal. However, I agree with #3 (GP18) point, “To crown David Archuleta as AI may mark a new era for the American public.” It is time for change and David Archuleta being a “quintessential AI” will make it happen.
I am also a David for life. It is my hope and prayers that all his heart desires will come true. Loving David deeply at his best and worst time is the true meaning of what we call L-O-V-E. We are at our early stage battling for David, my sword is daily sharpened for David Archuleta whom I adore -- The American Idol.
😉
Rascal,
You always seem to hit the nail right on the head. I totally agree with your assessment of American Idol/19 Entertainment. I will continue to vote for David Archuleta just because he wants to win so badly. I will also continue to pray that the best things will work out for him so he can continue to bless the world with his music.
No matter what the outcome of American Idol is David A. has captured my heart and my attention. So when his first CD is released I will be casting my vote for David, not by dialing a phone number, but by buying his CD.
Just remember David and his family in your thoughts and prayers.
I hear you, Rascal. I really do. I think AI has their clutches in him, win or lose, and that said, well, I want the confetti landing on his eyelashes. Because I think he would be so deeply moved by it. Because he deserves it.
But, like somebody said, If he doesn’t win, I’ll take my solace in your wise, always eloquent words.
I listened to a radio show today that featured Richard Parkinson, David’s music arranger and pianist, for the last 2 1/2 years. He said that they had worked out a new, contemporary version of “Longer” for David’s performance this Tuesday. He said it was hot, that it would have been the only thing people were talking about today. However, Ameican Idol producers shot it down, told them they had to do a straight cover of John Fogelberg’s song.
Anybody smelling something ROTTEN? I am!! Why on God’s green earth would they prevent an incredibly talented 17 year old kid from making an OLD song current? It might make David too appealing to some uncommited voters? They put the kabosh on his more current, pop version of “Think of Me” that David and his dad came up with, too. Wouldn’t that sort of thing be just what they wanted--someone unique with a new vibe? Sounds suspicious to me, like they’re working against DJ.
Then, they take away his monitor which he needs in order to hear himself over the top of all the girls screaming for him and the loud, blaring music. Since David is the one and only contestant who sings runs and rearranges and mixes up a song on the fly, he’s the one most hurt by their action.
I would love to see David snatch victory out of their dirty, stinking hands. Grrr… Should David pull off the win, one thing good about him being underaged is that Jeff will be there looking out for our guy. His dad is not as the media has been portraying him, but I do think he’d be a good advocate for David and would not let him be overly manipulated or steamrolled. He’s an older adult with some experience in the business and would defend David strongly, if necessary. He loves David dearly.
Well, a little over a week and one agony will be over--wondering and worrying about how DJ will do and the outcome--and another will begin. I am sharing some of the trepidation others have voiced. David has touched my heart and life so profoundly that I will miss him terribly. I wish Brett, the family, or someone else would realize how ardent and undying our affection for David is and continue to work with us.
A blurb or two, a short article once a week or so with some pictures or a video of what is happening with David would be sufficient for us to feel connected and happy as we noted his progress. We could begin to wean ourselves away from our entanglement with that angel, David. We could start to rediscover our old lives, yet still be enriched by our association with David and our interest in his journey. We’d soon enough find balance in our lives again while watching our little star begin to glow brighter and brighter. Sounds like a happy prospect, and I hope it happens.
If I have to go cold turkey, ain’t gonna be pretty! (Ha!) Sorry for babbling on and on, but David has really captivated me unlike anything I have ever experienced in my life. The end of Idol seems like impending doom. Is that melodramic enough? I thought so.
I have no words to add to Rascal’s or to the heartfelt comments above.
I’ll just restate Bookaholic’s words:
“David has really captivated me unlike anything I have ever experienced in my life.”
I remain, truly and deeply, dazed and confused.
The time -- Wednesday night,9:40 PM, May 14th. American Idol just finished here in in SLC,Utah, as I know it has for most of David’s fans. It was just announced that the finale this time next week will be between David and David. This scenario was forcast here about 2 months ago.
Right after the show was over, I got online to see what reactions there were that had been posted since earlier in the day when I checked. I know a lot of you probably do this too. I found an interview from Dean Kaelin, David Archuleta’s voice coach, who went to David’s performance Tuesday night. He told Fox 13, Utah,that he thought David sounded better on TV than he did in the Idol auditorium. Dean went on to describe some of the behind the sceens machinations and song switches that were made in the last week.
This speaks to the point that Rascal has offered to us to consider about what David’s life would be like should he win this thing. I have read many of the comments offered on this thread and agree on only one thing: I wish for David only what is best for him. ZabaSearch Phone & Text Results show David vs David in the Finals, posted before the show aired, with David COok receiving more votes this week than our David did. I do not know if that foreshadows anything for next wee, but it seems to be the “humdinger” finale that Simon wanted.
No one warned us that this journey with David would be easy. David, I think never expected to still be standing for the finale, judging by his reaction. This time next week, all will be revealed. Join me this week in prayer and meditation for the benefit of our Rebel.
Your sophistry--no matter how eloquent--will not succeed in deterring me from voting for David. It should be obvious to everyone concerned that David wants to win this competition. I couldn’t possibly bear to look at his sad little face in the wake of Ryan’s announcement of Cook’s accession to the AI throne, all the while knowing that I had been complicit in his demise by failing to support him. “Sorry.”
baobabs727 -- For the record, I never suggested that fans should not vote for David or even that I would not join in the rejoicing should he win. I merely said that I hope he doesn’t, because I see no downside to a second place finish (other than for fans who will be denied their vicarious thrill) and some very definite downsides to a win. I cannot presume to know what would be best for David. No one can. But that is inevitably what will happen.
You’re right. Sometimes I would question myself whether this is what David really wants or what I really want for him. The thrill that comes from seeing the boy wonder that he is shove the AI crown under his belt is just one of the many driving forces that keeps me voting for him every week. Although we all know full well that American Idol is far below David in his talent and his inevitable success, we also must recognize that American Idol serves as a very good starting point to build David’s confidence into the almost certain legend in the music industry that he will become. With all of it’s rigging, manipulation, and underhanded attacks, amongst other things, American Idol will never be able to drag down David’s enormous talent. No matter how hard American Idol will try to categorize David into a particular genre, they will not succeed for the simple fact that David knows who he is and why he sings. Therefore, winning the American Idol crown will only benefit David because he will be gaining two core ingredients to help him on his way to the top—experience and exposure. Those are the only two things David will be getting from American Idol and that’s all he needs from them. Although he’s already gotten some of both already, winning the crown can only exponentiate their amounts and that’s a good thing.
David A is in the final. Everything happen for a reason, so win or lose, there will be a purpose.
I was going to wait for rascal to put up a “homecoming video” thread, but he know I’m too impatient for that, so I’ll just say it here:
Did anyone else notice that when AI was showing David and his mom driving around the track, waving to the fans they were playing Imagine and when the words ” Imagine all the people” played- they panned to the HUGANTIC crowd? I really liked that -- that was pretty cool.
I only discovered this site a few days ago and blown away by the eloguent writing of “rascal” and how much it spoke to what I was thinking and feeling about David Archuleta but couldn’t put into words.
First, a bit about myself. I’m 44 years old, male, a professional involved in the classical music business for 25 years. I say this only because the media would have you believe that David’s only fans are hysterical little girls. In my circle of friends all of the people I know who like David are between 40 and 58 years old. So much for media stereotypes.
I have never watched AI until this season. I don’t like pop or rock or country music. I grew up on classical music, opera, and jazz. A friend told me early on that I had to hear the show because there was this 16 year old kid with one of the most beautiful voices he’d ever heard. I was skeptical. I watched.
The first episode I saw was where David sang “Imagine.” It’s a song I don’t like. And I don’t like John Lennon. 20 seconds into David’s singing of it I had tears in my eyes. He made that minor song sound like something written by Schubert. That’s a gift. A rare gift.
David’s voice is the purest, most beautiful I have ever heard in a person that young. And I know voices if I don’t say so myself. Some of my clients are among the biggest stars in opera. But beautiful voices are just beautiful voices. David’s has more than just beauty. It connects. And it’s that combination that is so rare. He connected me instantly and I’m not a teenager who is attracted to him because he’s cute. I’m attracted to his singing because it touches me. Very few artists can do that and almost none at his tender age.
So I was hooked. I have watched since having to wade through some of the worst singing I’ve ever heard (paging Jason Castro) to hear David’s stuff. I will admit that I think some of his song choices are very poor. Especially that song about the gun and that thing he sang on Tuesday night that he chose. At his age, he needs to stick to the things that suit his voice. It is something I tell my clients all the time. Don’t take on roles until your voice is ready.
I understand Rascal’s point about not wanting David to win AI. I don’t agree with it for, perhaps, a selfish reason. I want David to win because I think it will validate that nice guys can finish first. I think it will be a thumb in the eye that celebrates 15 year olds having sex and babies and acting out in awful ways. Kids like David give us old fogeys hope about the future. I want him to win to say to the world that it isn’t Britney Spears and Lindsey Lohan who are the representatives of youth in America but David Archuleta. He’s an extraordinary role model. But I also realize that’s putting a lot of pressure on his narrow shoulders.
So, in the end, I want him to win because he deserves it. He’s the best singer on the show, by far. I also want him to win because he seems to really want to. I want him to be happy.
I think many of us older folks who are his fans feel very “protecitve” of this young man that we don’t even know. He gives off that kind of vibe. You want to take him and make him safe from all the bad in the world.
But I want him to go out into the world with this title and spread the joy and love through his music that he so obviously possesses.
Long live David Archuleta!
Rascal, as usual, your comments are spot on. I, too, am torn about DJ winning the AI title. I know that he wants it, so I’m going to do everything I can to help him achieve that goal, but I am leery of what the 19E Machine will do with someone with so much sweetness, talent and potential. The thing that gives me comfort is that David is incredibly grounded for a 17 year-old. In many ways, while he has a lot of learning yet to do, he’s mature beyond his years. The way in which he conducts himself and the unending compassion that he shows for others does indeed put him head and shoulders above a lot of people twice his age.
In the end, win or lose, David is simply an extraordinary individual. AI will never change that.
Rascal, I have to admit I am adicted to your comments. My husband and I have wondered since the beginning if the AI crown is good for David or not. I cannot vote, I am in Panama, but if I could I would dial until my phone could no longer take it. I think America, our youth, the world need more Davids. And that is why I want him to win. Besides from the obvious fact that he deserves it. Thank you again for your comments. You seem to know how to put in words what our hearts want to say.
And by the way, I’m also not a teenager, but a 38 year old mother of 5, who wishes to thank the Archuletas for raising such a fine young man, his values, principles, modesty, humility make me smile every time I watch him.
Thank you.
To Randyisgreat
What you said!
as long as david is singing his heart out, he deserves our support.
i agree with most of what you wrote, and “yes” david is the true iconoclast…the real rebel. it’s part of why i enjoy listening to and watching him perform.
i have enjoyed AI, with the impression that i was watching kids compete musically--a real talent contest. i think AI itself this year has exposed my own naivety to me. one of the things that david exudes is innocence. i think i’m feeling robbed of a bit of my own innocence as i realize that innocence, integrity and quality may not be enough to turn the heads of a corporate interest like AI. i am reminded again of how rare a gift david is and amazed that he has come this far.
however it plays out, i will support david through the finale. i owe him that. but it would take another david a. to get me to watch AI again.
this week left me feeling just a little dirty for participating--definitely less naive.
oops, I commented elsewhere thinking that you, Rascal, decided to wholeheartedly support David, in spite of your completely understandable misgivings about AI, and I was happy. But anyway, I was responding to another fan’s posting. Because AI is what David himself wants, I want to see him reach his dreams. Nobody knows what would ultimately be the best thing, except, shall I say, God? so knowing that, I have faith that whatever the outcome, it will always be the best thing in the grand scheme of things.
I’m finding my own reaction to David’s song choices interesting. I was so impressed with Imagine and Long and Winding Road. His soulful re-workings of these tunes touched me in ways I can’t explain. David has my undying respect for bringing these tunes back to me, anew. His short, perfect rendition of “Heaven” had me covered in goose bumps. And this was a song I had alwys been indifferent to.
Like many of those commenting here, I’m not alone in my dislike of much of the music being played on AI. Having said that, I’m finding ways to appreciate music I would normally ignore simply because David is singing it. I’m not a fan of a lot of what passes for R&B and Soul these days. I find most of it so lacking in real feeling. But David made me listen to and enjoy Mariah Carey’s, “When you Believe”. Like-wise, Chris Brown’s “With You”. Never heard the song before David sang it and now after hearing the original, think that he did a fine job. I’m with Rascal here, it was only David’s confidence that was lacking enough to disallow him from taking full command of the performance. But you could see him gaining that control and feeling the joy in it as he warmed up to the vibe. It felt so good to see him smiling and connecting with the girls during that performance. I think the criticisms are off base. David’s delivery on this song actually mimes CB’s in tone and rhythm; it’s as close to a straight reading of anyone’s song that David has tried. Incidentally, Simon’s comments were way out of line. There’s nothing of the “tiger’ in CB’s original either. It’s a sweetly sentimental pop tune. Also, it was David’s “musical soul” that had him swaying and keeping bodily time to the groove, hence his response to Simon, “I was dancing??” It made no difference that Simon qualified his Chihuahua comment with “in-as-much-as blah blah…”, the damage was done. It couldn’t wipe away the demeaning image he tried to conjure up. Simon’s comment was on level with the trash you read by the cynical “journalists”, who seek to tear David down. His comments appear to be an example of the de-pimping that people refer to. BTW, I still believe something was rotten in the judge’s slagging of David’s “We can work it out”. Other than the missed words it was a solid performance- their criticisms were way out of proportion. (And damn right, David can do Stevie Wonder! )
There’s an inner struggle to maintain objectivity, as one becomes a fan of a particular artist. We are so bent on supporting them that we become forgiving of their lesser work and even find ways to enjoy it simply because it’s their creation. (ie: Having been a U2 fan from the beginning I found this to be the case with their last recording.) I’m fairly certain that my appreciation for David at his musical best, combined with my respect for his fine qualities as a person, is bending my ear to favorably receive anything he decides to sing. The only exception I can think of is ND’s “Coming to America” a tune so irritating that it might have the effect of turning people back to their homelands. I apologize to anyone who likes it, but that one has always grated on me. You have to admire David’s determination, though. He apparently struggled with trying to find Neil Diamond tunes that he could really feel. He used his mother’s Honduran origins as a touchstone for his connection to that song’s message. But not even that noble sentiment could cut through the bland musicality of the thing.
A major component of David’s power to move us is his ability to inject emotion into key sections of a familiar tune. He was able to accomplish this by re-arranging a single note with “ Long and Winding Road” “anyway you’ll never know…” That “you’ll” had such a note of desperation to it, I found myself welling up. I know others were moved similarly. This is what I would truly love to see this week: for David to take a familiar tune and simply blow us all away with his genius rendition of it. I have confidence that he will close this competition on a high note showing everyone the pure light of his shining spirit.
Thanks to Rascal and to anyone reading for the opportunity to ramble on.
All the power to David regardless of what happens this week. What an amazing performer, what an amazing kid! He deserves the best!
Bookaholic, thanks for babbling on. I’m right with you. I feel like I did, coming home from summer camp as a kid, didn’t want it to end. We’re going to have to re-learn our normal lives again.
I’m only sorry I found this site so late. It was a lonelier ride before this past week. Reading so many others who are affected by David in the same way has been very re-assuring. (I haven’t lost my mind, after all!)
Ariadne1880, I have felt that protective instinct from the first night I saw him perform. David’s lack of artifice and good nature are more emblematic of someone much, much younger. As Rascal said, it’s rare to find a teen that hasn’t built up the protective layers. It feels instinctive to move in and protect a kid who seems so pure and good. I’m also a father of two teen boys, both musical, and one David’s age. Every time I read some snarky columnist cutting him down it felt as if it was directed at one of my own boys. It felt so personal. As another commented in this site, I was sharpening my sword in anticipation.
I also have this feeling that our desire for David’s happiness above all, is somehow a reciprocal arrangement brought on by his “making us feel what he feels” through song. David’s accomplished this already and we feel a debt of gratitude towards him for it. It’s this kind of magical organic connection that can catch on and one day change the world…
Ariadne1880, I feel compelled to re-iterate your cheer “long live David Archuleta”…long live the king!
Rascal…I just stumbled on your site and was so pleased to hear from so many people who feel just as I do about this fine young man. He truly was the only reason that I watched this season. I can only hope and pray that coming in second was the best thing that could have happened. to him as it relates to his career..because he truly deserved to win. It would be wonderful if we could hear from him through a video since so many of us are wondering how he is doing since the competition ended and what plans he has for his future. What are the chances of this?
What a joy it was to read your commentary on “Our David”. I must say I agree with it. You know people might not know that David may have lost because some of his supporters simply wanted him to come in second. While coming in second merely means you didn’t win; in this case it meant you did. So some supporters didn’t vote for him.
We newly crowned “Fanatics” have Daivd’s best interest (we think) at heart. And I think it is proving to be a good thing. Please don’t misunderstand me here. I would have loved to have seen David’s face when his name was announced as winner, but alas, he has bigger fish to fry. And man is he frying them!
David James Archuleta is turning the “Pop Tarts Tour” up-side down and round and round and back again. His performances are clear evolution of that 12 yr. old little boy who was on “Star Seasch” more than five years ago. That little David Archuleta sang his heart out. This 17 yr. old David sings from his heart. Oh man, tears are starting to chke me up. Well I did manage more than one sentence this time.
Trying to describe David’s performances ihas become a chore as all the superlatives and adjectives ahve been used at least a thousand times. Where are Tony Randall and William F. Buckley when you need them. RIP.
I have said of “Our David” that he is a statement wrapped in an enigma. That he is a prodigy savant. I have said that I am crystal and he note shatter me. And trust me they do. I have said he is the child every household needs. Clone this kid.
David is as I have also said the epitome of an American Idol. And Randy Jackson, who never lied to David, even though David never got Randy’s comments, said of David…”You are so good. I thought, you are exactly what this show is about.” I whole-heartedly agreed.
I never watched the first season of this show and only a few episodes of season two, I watched more of Three and four, then dropped off again. FOr some reason I watched this show from the tryouts. And David was a blur to me. Now he is hypnotic. Spellbinding. Mood altering. Healing. Comforting. Amazing. Sensational. Heartwrenching. Pulse pounding. He wakes you up and never allows you to nap. Your day is all about David James archuleta. My favorites is being comppiled of Videos by DJA, Pics of DJA, interviews of well you get the ppicture. And I’m not the only one. The Tour will be over all to soon and we’ll not see “Our David” except for appearances. So I’m loading up.
I’m also praying The Tour will be filmed and marketed. AI and Pop Tarts have no idea what a money making venture this season’s Idols are. Especially the out of country markets who will never see The Tour. ANyway, I had a few question for you Rascal and others who may wish to comment.
1) Why is this site so dark, It’s holy heck on my poor vision. WHat I won’t do for David.
2) Did you have a problem with David’s singing with his eyes closed?
3) Do you think David held his abilities in check while doing AI?
4) Do you think David has Idol worship? Sorry David; I blogged to you about this so, it shouldn’t be surprising.
5) What do you think was going on with David on finale Tuesday? Why do you think David was so stunned? Ryan had to forcibly turn David and move him. I thought one thing, but I have come to believe something else.